Gospel Disharmony - MisreadBible

Gospel Disharmony

22nd February 2021

As I’m currently working on my fourth book covering the gospels, I thought I’d write about some of their issues, and how I am dealing with them in order to write the book. In this post, I’ll be focusing on the issues, and I plan to write a follow up addressing how I am dealing with them.

As you may know, the Bible is riddled with contradictions, and it’s not at all surprising given that it was written by multiple authors with different religious views over a period of centuries. Often authors would write narratives based on the same source, and the resulting stories would have some common elements but differ many ways. I gave an example of this in my earlier post Sister-Wives and the Documentary Hypothesis.

When it comes to the gospels, they all purport to tell the story of Jesus’s life and ministry, and there is evidence that a lot of material comes from common sources. The majority of scholars hold that Mark was written first (circa AD 66-70), and Matthew and Luke (written circa AD 85-90) used some version of it and one or more other source (scholars call this Q, from the German Quelle meaning ‘source’). As these three gospels share a large amount of material, they are known as the Synoptic Gospels.

They tell the story of Jesus’s birth (in Matthew 1-2 and Luke 1-2), his baptism by John the Baptist, and his ministries in Galilee and Judaea (a timespan of around a year), ending with his crucifixion, and post-resurrection appearances (in Matthew 28 and Luke 24. The oldest copies of Mark cut out before any post-resurrection appearances), but the order of events varies from gospel to gospel.

The Gospel of John (written circa AD 90-110), on the other hand, has mostly unique material, sharing only a few stories with the Synoptic Gospels. Where in the synoptics, Jesus is baptised by John and then returns to Galilee, in the Gospel of John, Jesus spends time with John, baptising alongside him. Where the synoptics have Jesus starting out in Galilee and moving towards Judaea, John has him constantly making trips to Jerusalem in Judaea for various festivals and says very little about his activities in Galilee. John’s version describes a period of around three years, as three separate Passover festivals take place.

Many attempts have been made by Christian scholars to reconcile (or harmonise) the gospels, creating an accurate timeline of events. This can take the form of a single merged narrative called a synopsis, or as a table of corresponding verses called a harmony.

Jesus’s Peraean Ministry

The contradictions between accounts are glaring, and the attempts to harmonise the gospels often create more issues than they resolve. One of the weird side-effects of harmonisation is the invention of a ministry not found in the text of the gospels: Jesus’s Peraean ministry.

In Mark 10 and Matthew 19, Jesus leaves Galilee for the region of Judaea and beyond the Jordan (Peraea). Presumably, Jesus’s discourse about divorce, the blessing of the little children, and the conversation with the rich young man took place here. Straight afterwards, he continues his journey to Jerusalem via Jericho. Peraea is merely one stop along his way during his journey.

In John 7, after Jesus’s brothers invite him to go to the Festival of Tabernacles (Sukkot), he travels down to Jerusalem alone and ends up preaching at the temple. There is no mention of him returning to Galilee, so presumably, he remained in Judaea. Then in John 10, he goes to the temple for the Festival of Dedication (Hanukkah), after which he retreats to Peraea. Nothing is mentioned about what he does in Peraea, and the next thing we read is that he went to Bethany, near Jerusalem, to resurrect Lazarus, and retreated to Ephraim in northern Judaea, and he set off from there for his final journey to Jerusalem.

However, in Luke, no mention is made of Peraea, and instead, in Luke 9, ‘Jesus resolutely set out for Jerusalem,’ and sent some of his disciples to a village in Samaria. When they are rejected, he goes to another unspecified village. Between Luke 9 and 18, his location isn’t reported, except for in Luke 17 when he’s said to be on the border between Galilee and Samaria. Then he continues on to Jericho (in Luke 18) to continue his journey to Jerusalem.

In an attempt to reconcile this, some harmonies place all or some of the events between Luke 9 and 18 (where no location is reported in the text) in Peraea and move Luke 17’s story of Jesus on the border of Galilee and Samaria back to when his disciples were rejected in Samaria. And thus, they have invented Jesus’s Peraean ministry.

Contradictory Order of Events

These are just some examples of some of the narratives that occur at different points in different gospels.

The Healing of the Paralytic at Capernaum

According to Mark 2, it took place when Jesus returned to Capernaum after calling the fishermen. According to Matthew 9, it took place as he was leaving the boat after crossing the Sea of Galilee from Gadara after curing two demon-possessed men. And according to Luke 5, it happened while he was ‘in one of the cities’ of Galilee preaching.

The Cleansing of the Temple

According to John 2, it took place at the beginning of Jesus’s ministry after the Wedding at Cana, but in the Synoptic Gospels (Mark 11, Matthew 21, Luke 19), it occurred towards the end when he was in Jerusalem before the crucifixion.

Contradictory Details

Here are some examples of narratives with even more contradictory details.

The Anointing of Jesus

A woman anoints Jesus with ointment.

Mark 14Matthew 26Luke 7John 12
TownBethanyBethanyDoesn’t sayBethany
In the house ofSimon the leperSimon the leperSimon the PhariseeLazarus
WhenJust before crucifixionJust before crucifixionGalilean ministryJust before crucifixion
WhoUnnamed womanUnnamed womanUnnamed sinful womanMary the sister of Martha
What she doesPours ointment over Jesus’s headPours ointment over Jesus’s headAnoints his feet and dries them with her hairAnoints his feet and dries them with her hair
Disciples were presentYesYesNoYes
The Exorcism of Legion

Jesus and his disciples cross the Sea of Galilee and are approached by one or two demon-possessed men and casts the demons into a herd of pigs.

Mark 5Matthew 8Luke 8
Came fromTombsTombsCity
The demoniac was nakedYesNoYes
Demons identify themselves as LegionYesNoYes
Man wants to join JesusYesNoYes
The Empty Tomb

After Jesus’s crucifixion Mary Magdalene goes to anoint his body.

Mark 16Matthew 28Luke 24John 20
Who goes to the tombMary Magdalene, Mary mother of James, and SalomeMary Magdalene, and the other MaryMary Magdalene, Joanna, Mary the mother of James, and a number of other womenMary Magdalene
Stone already rolled awayYesNoYesYes
Guards presentNoYesNoNo
Who they seeA young man in white in the tombAn angel descending outside tombTwo men in shining clothes in the tombNobody
Women enter the tombYesNoYesNo
Peter enters the tombNoNoYesYes
They see resurrected Jesus immediatelyNoYesNoNo
Disciples toldThe women are ordered to, but instead flee in terrorYesYesYes
This website is using cookies. Nothing insidious, just for the post rating system. That's Fine